Comparing Automatic and Manual transmissions


Automatic vs. Manual: Which One Should You Choose?

Trying to decide between a stick shift or an automatic? Mr. Transmission can help you take a closer look at the ins and outs of both automatic and manual transmissions and give you the lowdown to make a choice that's right for you.

What’s the Difference?
To make an informed decision, you need to grasp the fundamental differences between automatic and manual transmissions. A manual transmission, often known as a stick shift, requires the driver to manually shift gears using a clutch pedal and a gear stick. In contrast, an automatic transmission does all the gear-shifting work for you, without a clutch pedal.

With high demand for automatic vehicles, manual transmissions are becoming increasingly rare. Only a small fraction of cars in the United States now come standard with a manual transmission. Only 35 car models in 2023 offered the option of a manual transmission, according to U.S. News and World Report.

Despite the limited number of stick shift vehicles currently available, there are signs they may be making a comeback. In 2020, manual transmission vehicles represented only 2.4% of vehicle sales at CarMax. Stick shift sales inched up to 2.9% of sales in 2022. Young male car buyers primarily drove the uptick, CarMax reports. Manual transmissions were most popular in New Mexico, Oregon, Washington, New York, and Connecticut.

Pros and Cons of a Stick Shift
Let’s explore some pros and cons to help you make an informed decision.


  • Fuel efficiency: With greater control over gear shifting, skilled drivers can optimize fuel consumption, often outperforming automatics by three to four miles per gallon.
  • Maintenance: Manual transmissions are simpler and often cheaper to maintain due to fewer moving parts.
  • Cost: Historically, manual vehicles are less expensive than their automatic counterparts.
  • Driver engagement: Many drivers prefer manuals for an enhanced driving experience and control, especially in challenging conditions like poor weather or uphill driving.


  • Availability: Finding new vehicles with manual transmissions is becoming increasingly difficult.
  • Learning curve: Operating a stick shift requires more skill and concentration, which can be challenging for inexperienced drivers or those who multitask while driving.

Automatic Transmissions: The Modern Standard
Automatic transmissions are now the norm, with an estimated 90% of vehicles on the road featuring automatic gearboxes.


  • Convenience: Automatics are easier to drive, especially in heavy traffic, as they eliminate the need to manually shift gears.
  • Accessibility: They are more accessible to a broader range of drivers, including those who may find operating a clutch difficult.
  • Resale value: Due to their popularity, automatic vehicles have better resale value.


  • Cost: Automatics can be more expensive to buy and maintain.
  • Fuel efficiency: Automatics were less fuel-efficient, though this gap is closing with modern advancements. 

Mr. Transmission: Your Car Repair Experts
Whether you choose an automatic or a manual transmission, proper maintenance is key. Mr. Transmission offers specialized services for both types of transmissions. Our expertise ensures that your vehicle receives the best care to remain efficient and reliable. We’re committed to providing quality service and customer education.

At Mr. Trnamission, we're equipped to handle the maintenance and repair needs of both automatic and manual transmissions. From fluid checks and changes to more complex repairs, our skilled technicians ensure your transmission runs smoothly, prolonging the life of your vehicle and maintaining its performance.

Get Road Ready at Mr. Transmission
Regardless of your choice, regular maintenance by a trusted provider like Mr. Transmission is essential to keep your vehicle in top condition. Find a location near you to get up to date on your maintenance and answer your transmission questions.


Let's Talk

Single Post Form

A contact us form.


related blogs

Steve Sargent Shares Summer Safety Tips

Check out these tips on how to save gas from our franchisee Steve at Mr. Transmission Milex of Cary, NC! Story originally published on Spectrum News.

Read More
How to Save Money on Car Repairs

How to Save Money on Car Repairs Is the high cost of owning a car prompting you to explore ways to save? Follow Milex-Mr. Transmission's five tips to trim car repairs to stay on track with your budget. The average American paid $1,015 per month to own and operate a new vehicle in 2023, up […]

Read More
Matt Crouch

Franchising Gives Family of Veterans a New Mission At the Mr. Transmission/Milex Complete Auto Care location in Kansas City, Missouri, auto repair is a family affair. Matthew Crouch and his family exemplify how military veterans can successfully transition to franchise ownership. Military Background: A Foundation for Success Matthew Crouch, his father Russell, and his brother […]

Read More
Transmission Replacement

Is It Time to Replace My Transmission? Facing the possibility of needing a transmission replacement can be discouraging, given the complexity and cost associated with the repair. But, if your car is reaching the 100,000-mile mark, it’s time to start planning for the possibility of a big-ticket repair to ensure it continues to run smoothly […]

Read More
Preparing Cars for Holiday Travel

Preparing cars for holiday travel from Steve Sargent at Mr. Transmission Milex of Cary, NC! Story originally published on

Read More
I’m a Mechanic: The Best $100 You Can Spend on Your Car’s Maintenance

You take your vitamins, eat well, exercise and wash your hands to prevent getting sick and going to the doctor’s office, and you should take the same preventative steps with your car. Maintaining your car can extend its life and help prevent major repairs that will cost you a fortune in the shop. Here are some […]

Read More

Winter in the United States is no joke for many parts of the country. The snow, ice, and biting cold can be a real challenge, especially for our cars. But with a little bit of prep, you can ensure your vehicle is ready to face the frosty months ahead. Here are Milex Mr. Transmission's recommendations […]

Read More
I’m a Mechanic: Here Are 8 Money-Saving Car Maintenance Tips for This Fall

With fall just around the corner, now is the perfect time to get your car in tip-top shape for the cooler, stormy months ahead. Taking steps to ensure your car is prepared for the season is crucial to not only ensure your safety but also to save money in both the short and long term. Who better […]

Read More
Protecting Cars from Extreme Summer Heat

Check out these great car care tips from Milex Mr. Transmission Oklahoma City owner Roman! Story originally published on KWTV.

Read More

Join our Oklahoma City Mr. Transmission/Milex owner Roman with some car care tips for going back to school as featured on Oklahoma's News 9!

Read More
1 2 3 20
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram